Norwegian children’s perceptions of effectiveness of social media companies’ cyberbullying policies: an exploratory study
Keywords
Social media
cyberbullying
policy
platforms
children’s rights
Publication details
Year: | 2020 |
DOI: | 10.1080/17482798.2019.1695219 |
Issued: | 2019 |
Language: | English |
Volume: | 14 |
Issue: | 1 |
Start Page: | 74 |
End Page: | 90 |
Editors: | |
Authors: | Milosevic T.; Vladisavljevic M. |
Type: | Journal article |
Journal: | Journal of Children and Media |
Publisher: | Informa UK Limited |
Topics: | Social mediation; Internet usage, practices and engagement; Wellbeing; Risks and harms; Online safety and policy regulation; Access, inequalities and vulnerabilities |
Sample: | This study draws on two survey datasets: 1. a smaller one (which we refer to as Survey A), where the fieldwork took place in April 2016 and was accompanied with focus groups 2. a larger one (EU Kids Online, from now on Survey B) where the fieldwork took place in 2018. We draw on two surveys as the small one contained more questions on the topic of effectiveness of social media companies’ policies. Survey A was conducted in an international school in an urban area of Norway with a total of 152 children (79 females, 73 males, Mage = 13.97 age range: 11 to 19 years). A hundred and seventy-five children in total agreed to participate in the survey but only 152 were available to take the survey. The questionnaire contained 32 questions – where children were asked to choose one or more options per question and some questions were open-ended. ... The data for Survey B was collected between June and October 2018 as part of the EU Kids Online research in Norway, on a nationally representative sample of 9–17-year-old children. 1001 children of both sexes, aged from 9 to 17 years were interviewed via CASI method. 47.1% of the sample was female, Mage = 13.3. |
Implications For Parents About: | Parental practices / parental mediation; Parenting guidance / support |
Implications For Educators About: | Digital citizenship; Professional development |
Implications For Policy Makers About: | Creating a safe environment for children online; Stepping up awareness and empowerment |
Implications For Stakeholders About: | Researchers; Industry; Healthcare |
Abstract
There is a paucity of research that examines the effectiveness of social media companies’ anti-bullying tools from the children’s perspective. This article relies on two datasets from Norway: A small-scale explora- tory survey and focus groups with children at one school in Norway; and the EU Kids Online survey with a nationally representative sam- ple of Norwegian Internet-using children, to examine whether chil- dren and young people aged 9–19 are aware of and whether they use social media companies’ mechanisms against cyberbullying (e.g., various types of reporting, blocking, and companies’ safety and help centers). We also examine the extent to which children find these tools to be helpful and the underlying reasons for such perceptions of the effectiveness of social media companies’ mechanisms. The study further inquires into children’s perceptions of company respon- sibility for providing assistance in bullying incidents. While the major- ity of children in both samples know how to use basic tools such as reporting, the levels of awareness of various companies’ advanced tools as well as the use of these, are relatively low. Children also have mixed perceptions as to whether companies are able to assist. Results are discussed from the framework of children’s rights, offering policy recommendations.
Outcome
Statistical analyses from both surveys indicate that most children know how to use or have used basic tools such as blocking and reporting. Nonetheless, they demonstrate limited familiarity with social media companies’ advanced tools (help and safety centers as well as social reporting-like tools). Children who were bullied and used reporting tools in such circumstances express mixed views as to whether such reporting was helpful. Consider that as many as 56% of children in Survey A who said they reported, never got an answer from the platform the last time this happened; and another 41% did not know what the outcome was the last time they reported.
In Survey B, awareness of all tools increases with age and children who were bullied online were more likely to have seen and used all tools. Awareness of various tools is similar across the most popular social media platforms, and no platform appears to perform better than others when it comes to awareness of its advanced tools.